How restaurants can build compensation packages that work

Restaurant Staff employees
(Getty Images/Fiona Goodall/Stringer)

For restaurant operators, compensation is no longer simply a question of how much an employee earns per hour. Wages remain central, but workers are increasingly evaluating the entire employment experience, including earning potential, schedule predictability, benefits, flexibility and opportunities for advancement.

That broader view is particularly important in an industry where labor costs remain a major operating expense and competition for reliable employees can be intense. A compensation strategy does not necessarily require restaurants to add a long list of costly perks. Instead, operators can focus on the elements employees actually value and build a package that makes sense for both the workforce and the restaurant’s financial realities.

“Wages are still a core issue,” said Rob Wilson, president of Employco, an HR solutions firm. But wage structures are changing in different markets. 

At Nashville-based Noko Hospitality, Founder Jon Murray said the company has found that employees increasingly view compensation through a quality-of-life lens. “We’ve found that compensation isn’t just about the hourly rate anymore. People want balance,” he said. “Pay is important, but so is time, flexibility and quality of life.”

Look Beyond the Hourly Rate

One challenge for operators is recognizing that an employee’s perception of compensation can differ from the employer’s calculation of labor costs. A restaurant may offer an attractive hourly wage, for example, but employees may place greater value on total earning potential, desirable shifts or employer contributions toward health insurance.

Wilson recommends establishing competitive base wages for the local market and then considering how tips, incentives, health insurance, paid time off, retirement contributions and other benefits complement that wage.

Murray said Noko made that broader approach part of its business model from the beginning. The company provides company-funded health insurance, four-day workweeks, complimentary therapy, gym and yoga memberships, paid birthdays off, PTO, flexible scheduling and an annual travel stipend. “For us, it’s the cost of doing business. It’s that simple,” Murray said. “You have to look at compensation as the entire package, not just the hourly wage.”

Those investments do not have to look identical at every restaurant. The important consideration is whether the benefits address actual employee needs. At Noko, Murray said health insurance, gym memberships, paid time off and the travel stipend are used by nearly everyone.

“The benefits that get used most consistently are the ones that affect people’s everyday lives,” he said. “The goal is to give people access to resources that can genuinely improve their lives when they need them.”

Operators should therefore evaluate benefits through enrollment and utilization data as well as employee feedback. A benefit that looks impressive on paper but attracts little participation may not provide the same value as a simpler benefit employees regularly use.

Make Tip Structures Transparent

Few compensation issues generate as much discussion in restaurants as tips. Whether a restaurant uses individual tipping, a tip-out arrangement or a broader tip pool, employees need to understand how the system works and how money is distributed.

“The real friction shows up” in disagreements between front- and back-of-house employees over tip distribution, Wilson said. Employees may question how much should go to the kitchen compared with servers, runners, bussers and other positions.

Damian Conforti, partner and chair of the Hospitality Services Practice at Mandelbaum Barrett PC, said fair tip-pooling practices are essential, but there is no single model that works for every restaurant. The appropriate approach depends on factors including staffing, clientele, tipping patterns and the culture of the establishment.

Noko does not use a service charge, a deliberate choice based on the company’s philosophy about who should be responsible for employee compensation. “We don’t believe the guest should have to bear the cost of taking care of our employees,” Murray said. “That responsibility belongs to us as the operator.”

Whatever model an operator chooses, communication is critical. Employees should understand who participates, how distributions are calculated and when payments are made. Operators should also periodically review whether the system is creating disparities or undermining teamwork.

Put Scheduling on the Compensation Menu

For hourly restaurant employees, scheduling can have an impact nearly as tangible as a traditional benefit. An employee who consistently receives desirable hours and knows when those hours will occur has more control over income and personal obligations.

Wilson said employees are more likely to stay when schedules are posted consistently and sufficiently far in advance and when last-minute changes are limited. Scheduling technology can help employees view schedules, submit requests and manage shift changes, but technology alone does not solve the problem.

Murray said flexibility is a central part of Noko’s retention strategy. “We talk internally about being in the business of finding ‘the yes’ for our people,” he said. “Our restaurants should not be the most important thing in somebody’s life. Their relationships, families and lives outside of work should be more important.”

Noko also relies on employees supporting one another when someone needs time away. “If one person needs coverage, somebody else steps up because they know that when they need time off, the team will do the same for them,” Murray said.

For operators, scheduling can therefore be a relatively low-cost component of a compensation strategy. Providing greater predictability and flexibility does not necessarily require increasing payroll, but it can substantially affect how employees experience their jobs.

Reward Without Undermining Teamwork

Bonuses and performance incentives can supplement wages, but poorly designed programs can create competition that works against a restaurant’s culture.

Wilson recommends objective, attainable and consistently applied eligibility requirements and performance standards. Restaurants can also consider team-based measures such as guest satisfaction, sales growth, safety, attendance or location-level profitability.

Murray takes a similar approach, avoiding bonuses based solely on individual results. “Sometimes a bonus should simply mean, ‘Thank you. We see what you’ve done, and we appreciate you,’” he said. Noko gives Christmas bonuses and other bonuses recognizing individual contributions.

“The most important thing is making sure incentives reinforce the culture you’re trying to build rather than encouraging people to compete against one another,” Murray said.

Make Career Growth Part of the Equation

Career development can provide another way for restaurants to retain strong performers. Employees want to know that working for a company can lead somewhere, whether through increased responsibility, new skills or greater compensation.

Wilson emphasizes putting employees in positions that match their strengths and identifying advancement opportunities for people who consistently perform well. “When you have a runner or other type of person that is loyal and does a great job, you need to look where that person can advance within your organization,” he said.

That advancement does not necessarily have to begin with management. Cross-training, trainer and shift-lead roles, mentoring, supervisor development and food-safety or beverage certifications can create pathways for employees to grow.

Murray said Noko makes education and professional development available through opportunities such as WSET training and industry conferences. “What matters is that people know the investment is there if they want to keep learning and growing,” he said.

Measure What the Strategy Produces

With labor budgets under pressure, restaurants cannot afford to add compensation costs without understanding whether those investments are producing results. The answer is not necessarily to spend more, but to spend strategically.

Noko’s experience provides one example of measuring the outcome of a broader compensation philosophy. The company has invested nearly $500,000 in employee benefits since opening in 2023 and reports employee turnover of roughly 14 percent, while spending about 5.5 percent of sales on employee benefits.

Operators should establish a baseline before making changes and then track metrics such as voluntary turnover, first-90-day turnover, average tenure, absenteeism, overtime, time to fill open positions, offer-acceptance rates and referral hires. Murray also recommends looking at whether employees actually use the benefits being offered and whether they refer others to the company.

“Are people staying? Are they referring their friends to work for you? Are employees taking advantage of what you offer? Do people want to grow within the company?” he asks.

Conforti suggests looking beyond HR metrics and paying attention to customers as well. “Customer feedback is key,” he said. “Feedback may be freely offered or directly sought from the customer, but there is no better measure of one’s capital investment than repeat business and strong revenues quarter after quarter.”

Ultimately, an effective compensation strategy is not simply about increasing wages or adding benefits. It is about understanding what employees value, determining what the restaurant can sustainably provide and making the connection between compensation and the employee experience clear.

As Murray put it, “You don’t necessarily need the biggest labor budget to make someone feel valued. You do need to be intentional about where you spend it.”